Peanut butter is a staple food in most households. It’s a great source of protein, healthy fats, and vitamins that can benefit humans and animals. For dogs in particular, peanut butter is an excellent treat as it provides them with the essential nutrients they need while being delicious and full of flavor! However, not all peanut butter are created equal, especially regarding organic options. Here at The IslandNow we want to provide you with the best organic peanut butter brands for your furry friends!

What Makes Organic Peanut Butter Different?

Organic peanut butter differs from its traditional counterparts in that it does not contain synthetic fertilizers, pesticides, or other chemicals. These chemicals have been linked to various health risks such as cancer and reproductive problems, so it’s important to make sure you choose the right kind of peanut butter if you’re concerned about your pup’s health. Also, organic peanut butter tends to have more natural flavorings, which can make it even tastier than regular peanut butter!

1- NuttZo Power Fuel Peanut Butter

NuttZo Power Fuel Peanut Butter is one of the best organic options on the market today. This tasty spread contains seven different types of nuts, seeds, and legumes that provide your dog with a variety of essential vitamins and minerals. This creamy blend also has no added sugar or salt, so you don’t have to worry about overfeeding your pup or giving him too much sodium. Plus, this product is made with non-GMO ingredients, so you know what they are getting is free from potentially harmful additives!

2- Cookies N Cream Peanut Butter Dog Treats

Cookies N Cream Dog Treats offers an organic peanut butter blend specially designed for dogs, combining crunchy peanut bits with sweet honey and sea salt. Not only will your pet enjoy the taste, but they will also get plenty of omega-3 fatty acids thanks to the use of flaxseed oil in each jar! Plus, these treats are gluten-free, making them perfect for those who may have sensitivities or allergies to certain ingredients found in regular snacks.

3- Crazy Richards Natural Creamy Peanut Butter

Crazy Richards Natural Creamy Peanut Butter is another popular option with pet owners due to its simple ingredient list, consisting of just roasted peanuts and some added palm oil for texture. This blend has no added sugar or preservatives, so there’s no need to worry about the potential health risks associated with consuming artificial sweeteners or additives commonly found in other brands. In addition, this product contains tons of beneficial vitamins such as vitamin E, which helps support a healthy coat and skin!

4- SpreadTheLove Organic Unsweetened Smooth & Crunchy

SpreadTheLove Organic Unsweetened Smooth & Crunchy offers two different varieties – smooth and crunchy – making it easy for pet owners who prefer one style over the other to feed their fur baby this snack-time favorite. Made with USDA-certified organic peanuts and only sea salt, this spread is both safe and nutritious without compromising on flavor! In addition, SpreadTheLove donates 10% of its profits to animal rescue organizations, so by purchasing this product you are also helping others in need!

5- Justin’s Classic Almond Butter

Justin’s Classic Almond Butter takes a step away from traditional nut butter by using almonds instead, which are still packed with nutrients and even add omega-3s! Not only does almond butter offer a great alternative for those who may be allergic or sensitive to peanuts, but its subtle sweetness means less sugar needs to be used compared to typical blends, making it an overall healthier choice for pups (and people) alike. On top of all that goodness, Justin’s products are also certified gluten-free, so everyone can enjoy this delicious treat guilt-free, knowing there won’t be any unforeseen consequences either way!

6 – Nature Nate’s 100% Pure Raw Honey

Nature Nate’s 100% Pure Raw Honey may not technically be classified as ‘peanut butter’ per se, but adding a spoonful to regular varieties can help give it an extra boost, while providing a host of valuable nutrients such as antioxidants, without having to worry about unhealthy additives either way! Additionally, raw honey has antibacterial properties which could come in handy if ever needed at times when illness might otherwise be unavoidable – although remember that moderation should always be practiced here as some breeds may react differently depending on individual sensitivities present in their bloodlines too!


Choosing the right type of peanut butter can often be difficult; especially when trying to factor in concerns regarding safety first before anything else too boot these days – thankfully though there are plenty of options available these days ranging from certified organic treats to tasty alternatives such as almond spreads even then… so long story short – whether canine companions prefer something smooth yet savory (or perhaps even slightly sweet?) then rest assured there are delicious solutions abounding just waiting around the proverbial corner after all, now also here at The IslandNow!